By Nicolas Rapold in the September-October 2015 Issue
Short Takes: 99 Homes
(Ramin Bahrani, U.S., 2014)
Ten years after Ramin Bahrani’s Man Push Cart, it’s hard not to admire the filmmaker’s success at marshaling multi-million-dollar social dramas with big movie stars. Say what you will about his 2012 At Any Price, but with 99 Homes, Bahrani puts a bona fide Spider-Man (Andrew Garfield) to work mopping up shit in a sewage-flooded house (while also giving Michael Shannon a red-meat role as a good-ol’-boy real-estate shark).
From the September-October 2015 Issue
Also in this issue
Go-getting Garfield plays Dennis Nash, a handyman who defaults on the house he shares with his mother (the ageless Laura Dern) and son. In Bahrani’s explicitly spelled-out exploit-or-be-exploited story, Nash swallows his ethics and takes a job with wealthy Mike Carver (Shannon) repossessing homes and engaging in various other money-making hijinks of dubious legality. But until he can wrest back ownership of his family’s house, at the end of the day he still goes home to live in a crowded strip motel with mom and kid, beset by the loud music of other long-term residents.
There’s something to be said for broadcasting the galling cash-in mentality of the Aughts housing-market scandal as loudly and clearly as Bahrani does here, in a screenplay co-written with Iranian director Amir Naderi. But the film feels far too cut-and-dried, right down to Mike’s booming Speech About America (which was made, in case you’re wondering, by and for the winners).
Sign up for the Film Comment Letter!
Thoughtful, original film criticism delivered straight to your inbox each week. Enter your email address below to subscribe.